The Atlanta Falcons have officially handed the starting quarterback role to rookie Michael Penix Jr., a bold mid-season shift as the team fights to remain in playoff contention. Kirk Cousins, the veteran quarterback signed to a massive deal this past offseason, will now be benched after just 14 games. Head coach Raheem Morris confirmed the move in a statement, emphasizing that it was made purely with the team’s current and future success in mind.
Kirk Cousins’ Struggles and the Falcons’ Dilemma
Cousins’ benching follows a string of underwhelming performances that have derailed the Falcons’ offensive efficiency. Despite signing a four-year, $180 million contract this offseason with $90 million fully guaranteed, Cousins has failed to meet expectations. According to Adam Schefter, Cousins is set to earn $62.5 million this season, with $27.5 million fully guaranteed next year.
While Cousins remains a proven passer, his struggles with red-zone execution, turnovers, and a lack of mobility became evident as the season progressed. The Falcons, sitting at a precarious 7-7, could not afford further stagnation with playoff hopes still alive.
The Falcons’ Playoff Chances: Narrow Margin for Error
Atlanta remains in the thick of the NFC South race, trailing the 8-6 Tampa Bay Buccaneers. However, according to Adam Schefter, the Falcons hold the critical tiebreaker over Tampa Bay, having beaten them twice this season. Their remaining schedule is favorable, with matchups against the Giants, Commanders, and Panthers—three teams with losing records.
By contrast, Tampa Bay faces a tougher road ahead, with games against the Cowboys, Panthers, and Saints. If the Falcons can win out under Penix’s leadership, they could leapfrog the Bucs and secure a playoff spot.
Drafting Michael Penix Jr.: Atlanta’s Forward-Thinking Move
The decision to draft Michael Penix Jr. raised eyebrows earlier this year, particularly after the team invested heavily in Kirk Cousins. However, the former University of Washington star was viewed as a long-term solution, possessing a big arm, exceptional accuracy, and an ability to stretch defenses vertically.
Penix’s college career demonstrated his ability to thrive under pressure, a trait the Falcons now hope translates to the NFL as they hand him the reins during this playoff push. Atlanta’s front office clearly drafted Penix with an eye on the future, and now, that future has arrived earlier than expected.
Penix Takes Over: A New Era Begins
Head coach Raheem Morris announced the decision this week, calling it a “football decision” aimed at sparking the offense and keeping playoff hopes alive. Penix’s skill set offers a stark contrast to Cousins’. Where Cousins lacks mobility, Penix brings an ability to extend plays, challenge defenses downfield, and energize a stagnant offense.
The rookie’s transition will not be without challenges. Penix is stepping into a high-pressure situation with the Falcons’ season hanging in the balance. However, his poise, leadership, and collegiate track record provide reason for optimism.
The Financial Impact of Benching Kirk Cousins
While the move to start Penix is driven by football, it carries significant financial implications for the Falcons. According to Adam Schefter, if the Falcons were to cut Cousins before the start of the 2025 league year, they would face $65 million in dead cap money. A trade, on the other hand, would allow the Falcons to transfer Cousins’ $27.5 million base salary to another team, leaving Atlanta responsible for $37.5 million in prorated cap hits.
Ian Rapoport adds that Cousins’ contract remains tradable, given his proven experience. However, with his current struggles and hefty financial commitments, Atlanta’s front office faces a critical offseason decision regarding his future.
Conclusion: A Bold Decision for the Falcons’ Future
The Atlanta Falcons have taken a significant step by benching Kirk Cousins in favor of Michael Penix Jr. As the rookie takes over, the team’s playoff hopes and long-term plans are now intertwined. The move is both a gamble and an opportunity—a chance to breathe life into an offense that has struggled and to evaluate their quarterback of the future.
With a favorable schedule ahead and the division still in reach, Penix’s performance will determine not just the Falcons’ postseason fate but also the trajectory of their franchise. As Atlanta prepares to face the New York Giants this week, all eyes are on Penix to see if he can deliver in a moment of urgency.
According to Adam Schefter and Ian Rapoport, this decision marks a turning point for Atlanta—one that could shape the Falcons’ immediate success and long-term identity.
Photo from Michael Penix Instagram.
